Mashed Potatoes

Whole russet potatoes simmered until just tender, peeled, riced, and enriched with hot half-and-half or milk, butter, and plenty of black pepper.

From America's Test Kitchen

Total time
45 minEstimated
Preparation
10 minEstimated
Cooking
35 minEstimated
Yield
6
To the recipe ↓
A mound of fluffy mashed potatoes on a dark plate with a serving spoon.

For a light, flavorful mashed potatoes recipe, we used high-starch potatoes such as russets. The right tool was important in getting the best result: For smooth mashed potatoes, a food mill or potato ricer fitted with the finest disk was the best choice. For chunky mashed potatoes, we used a potato masher. Finally, cooking time was important in our mashed potatoes recipe. We cooked the potatoes until they were just tender, but not falling apart (a paring knife could be slipped in and out of the potatoes with very little resistance), taking care not to overcook them.

Preparation

  1. Place whole potatoes in large pot with cold salted water to cover. Bring to boil over high heat then simmer, covered, until potatoes are just tender (about twenty minutes). Drain. Peel potatoes and put through food mill or ricer into a warm, dry saucepan.

  2. Heat milk and butter in small saucepan until warm and butter is melted. Pour milk/butter mixture into potatoes and mix well. Generously season with lots of pepper and serve.

Notes

Buy our winning potato ricer: https://cooks.io/2OkCb3g

Nutrition

Serving size per serving

Calories 240 calories

About these timings
Saved total time
29min

Total time estimate: The source's 29 minutes is about the length of the 20-minute simmer alone. Bringing a large pot of cold water to a boil, then peeling and ricing the hot potatoes, adds about 15 minutes.

Preparation estimate: Covers peeling and ricing the cooked potatoes and warming the milk and butter.

Cooking estimate: Covers bringing the potatoes to a boil from cold water and simmering them until just tender, about 20 minutes.

Times include passive waits where applicable. Follow the original temperatures and doneness cues when cooking.

Filed under Holiday

Added to the collection . Recipe text and photographs retain their original attribution.